BARELYPUBLIC

ROOM 01 · FILED UNDER FALSE CLEARING

The Man Who Believed the Flamingo Was Hiding

In 1909 a painter in New Hampshire put a flamingo in front of a sunset and declared it invisible. His name was Abbott Handerson Thayer, and he is a large part of the reason the word camouflage means anything to an army. He was right about shadows, half right about ships, and wrong about the flamingo. The flamingo is the part people remember.

I.

Before the birds, there were angels. For a while in the 1890s, Thayer was the man America went to for them: tall, pale figures with wings, often painted from his own children, standing very still against almost nothing.

Then he noticed the shadow.

Look at almost any animal from the side. Dark on the back, pale on the belly. Sunlight falls from above and darkens whatever faces down, and the pale belly quietly cancels it out. The animal goes flat. A flat thing in a world of round things is very hard to see.

Thayer proved it with wooden decoys, painted dark on top and white underneath, set out where anyone could look straight at them. They disappeared in plain view. Biologists still call the principle Thayer's Law. It may be the only law of nature named after a man who painted angels.

II.

A good idea, left alone with a stubborn man, starts to want to be the only idea.

Thayer began to see concealment everywhere. The peacock's tail was a forest of leaves and light. The blue jay was a winter afternoon. And the flamingo, the pinkest thing alive, was pink so it could dissolve into the sky at dawn and dusk, the hours it feeds with its face buried in the mud and cannot watch for anything.

He painted all of it, with his son Gerald and a small company of students, and in 1909 they published the paintings as Concealing Coloration in the Animal Kingdom. Thayer did not describe the book modestly. It presented, he said, "not theories, but revelations."

III.

Theodore Roosevelt was in Africa when the book came out, shooting the animals Thayer said could not be seen.

Roosevelt had spotted several of them from miles away, standing in the open, making no effort to hide. He came home and wrote a rebuttal one hundred and twelve pages long.

Thayer's reply was an invitation. Come to New Hampshire, he said, and let me show you. He made the offer to the former president more than once. In 1911 he made it to the public, in print, begging his readers to come to Monadnock and see for themselves.

Roosevelt never went.

One man had looked and was certain. The other wanted to teach him how to look. Neither could see what the other saw, which was the entire argument, small enough to fit in a letter.

IV.

In 1914 the war arrived, and armies discovered the problem Thayer had been describing for nearly twenty years: being seen gets you killed.

He had spent years pressing the military to cover uniforms and ships in broken shapes. When he finally got to paint warships, his patterns made it hard to tell which way a ship was even moving.

That first winter in Paris, Picasso was walking down the Boulevard Raspail with Gertrude Stein when a camouflaged truck went past at night. He stopped. C'est nous qui avons fait ça, he said. We made that. That is cubism.

So the idea had two fathers, an ocean apart. One found it in birds and was laughed at. The other found it in Cézanne and took a bow.

The French needed a word for the new thing, and they took it from Paris slang. Camoufler: to blow smoke in someone's face.

V.

Thayer died in 1921 in Dublin, New Hampshire, in sight of the mountain he kept inviting people to.

History settled his case the way it settles most cases. It kept the parts it could use. His shadows went into textbooks. His broken shapes went to war. And the flamingo was left exactly where he painted it, standing in the sunset, looked at by everyone and seen by almost no one.

FILED UNDER: False Clearing

EXHIBIT: False Clearing →

BARELY PUBLIC. Avant-garde separates. Made in New Delhi.

SOURCES CONSULTED: Smithsonian American Art Museum, Thayer studies for Concealing Coloration in the Animal Kingdom; Roy R. Behrens, "Revisiting Abbott Thayer," Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B (2009); Abbott H. Thayer, "Concealing Coloration," Popular Science Monthly vol. 79 (1911); JSTOR Daily, "Teddy Roosevelt, Evolution and Camouflage"; Gertrude Stein, The Autobiography of Alice B. Toklas (1933).

NEXT ROOM: The Man Who Moved One Street Away